The Biggest Holiday Facebook Ads Mistake? Turning Off Campaigns That Are Actually Working

Should you pause your Facebook ads during Thanksgiving and Christmas? Not necessarily. Here’s why higher ad costs don’t always mean lower profits.

It’s November. Black Friday is approaching. Your Facebook ad costs are creeping up, and every retailer on the planet seems to be throwing money at Meta.

So naturally, you start wondering…

Should I just turn off my Facebook ads until after the holidays?

After all, advertising costs tend to increase this time of year. Why spend more money competing with all those holiday advertisers when you could just wait until January?

Sounds logical, right?

Well, not so fast.

Because one of the biggest holiday advertising mistakes I see business owners make is turning off campaigns based on what they THINK will happen instead of looking at what’s actually happening.

And I’ve got a real client example that illustrates exactly why this can be such an expensive mistake.

Why Facebook Ad Costs Can Increase During the Holidays

First, let’s talk about why advertising costs sometimes go up this time of year.

Meta uses an auction system to determine which ads get shown. And during the holidays, you’ve got retailers, e-commerce brands, and businesses of all sizes competing for people’s attention.

More competition can mean higher CPMs (cost per 1,000 impressions), which can also lead to higher costs per click and higher costs per lead.

But here’s something important to understand:

Just because advertising costs increase doesn’t mean your campaigns are performing worse.

And this is especially important if you’re a coach, consultant, or service-based business owner.

You’re probably not competing directly with Amazon or Target for holiday shoppers. You’re selling something completely different to a different audience.

Sure, the overall advertising environment can affect your costs, but that doesn’t automatically mean your ideal clients have stopped paying attention or buying.

Which brings me to a client I’ve worked with for years.

The Holiday Advertising Strategy That Was Costing My Client Money

I have a client who regularly launches during the holidays.

Her campaigns generate registrations for a webinar, where she sells her offer.

And yes, sometimes the cost of those webinar registrations increases during November and December.

But here’s the interesting part.

Her webinar sales are still excellent. And so is her return on ad spend (ROAS).

Before we started working together, her previous ads manager routinely turned off her campaigns over Thanksgiving and Christmas, then restarted them after the holidays.

The assumption was that holiday advertising would be more expensive, so it made sense to pause.

But when I took over, I made a different decision.

We were going to keep the ads running.

Why?

Because even when her cost per lead increased, those leads were still turning into paying customers.

And ultimately, that’s what matters.

We weren’t running ads just to collect the cheapest possible webinar registrations. We were running ads to generate sales.

By keeping the campaigns running, we continued bringing in leads and generating revenue instead of interrupting campaigns that were already working.

And since making that change, her ROAS has improved.

The takeaway?

A higher cost per lead doesn’t automatically mean your advertising is less profitable.

Sometimes spending a little more to acquire a lead is absolutely worth it when those leads are converting into sales.

Why Constantly Pausing and Restarting Ads Can Hurt Performance

There’s another reason I’m not a fan of automatically turning ads off for every holiday.

Momentum matters.

Meta’s advertising algorithm uses performance signals to determine how and where to deliver your ads.

When a campaign is performing well, Meta is gathering information about the people most likely to take the action you want.

Pausing a campaign interrupts that delivery.

Now, to be clear, a short pause doesn’t automatically reset the learning phase or ruin your campaign. But repeatedly turning campaigns on and off can create unnecessary fluctuations in delivery and performance.

And when you’re running a time-sensitive launch, those interruptions can be particularly costly.

Think about it.

If your campaign is consistently generating qualified leads and profitable sales, why would you voluntarily stop bringing those people into your funnel?

Especially when your audience might be perfectly happy to register for a webinar or invest in your offer during the holidays.

The calendar alone isn’t a good enough reason to pull the plug.

Stop Obsessing Over CPC and CPL. Look at What Happens Next.

This is one of the biggest things I wish more business owners understood about Facebook advertising.

Metrics like CPM, CPC, and CPL are useful.

But they’re not the whole story.

Let’s say you’re running ads to a webinar.

During October, your cost per registration is $8.

In November, it increases to $11.

At first glance, that might look like your ads are getting worse.

But what if the people registering in November are more likely to attend your webinar and purchase your offer?

What if you’re generating more revenue for every dollar spent?

Would you really want to shut those ads off just because your leads cost $3 more?

Of course not.

Those numbers are hypothetical, but the principle is important.

Your cost per lead tells you what you’re paying to acquire a lead. It doesn’t tell you what that lead is worth.

That’s why I encourage my clients to look beyond the front-end advertising metrics.

Depending on your business and funnel, you should also be paying attention to:

  • Lead quality: Are you attracting people who are actually interested in what you offer?
  • Webinar attendance: Are people showing up after they register?
  • Sales conversion rate: How many of those leads become paying customers?
  • Cost per acquisition (CPA): How much are you spending to acquire an actual customer?
  • Return on ad spend (ROAS): How much revenue are you generating for every dollar you spend on advertising?

Because at the end of the day, I’d rather have a campaign generating $5 in revenue for every $1 spent than one generating super-cheap leads that never buy anything.

Wouldn’t you?

When SHOULD You Adjust or Pause Your Holiday Facebook Ads?

Now, none of this means you should blindly keep throwing money at campaigns that aren’t working.

There are absolutely situations where reducing your budget, changing your strategy, or pausing your ads makes sense.

For example:

1. Your cost per acquisition is no longer sustainable.

If your advertising costs are increasing and your sales aren’t keeping pace, that’s a problem worth addressing.

2. Your lead quality has noticeably declined.

Cheap leads aren’t helpful if they’re not qualified. But expensive leads aren’t automatically better, either. You need to look at what happens after someone opts in.

3. Your conversion rates are dropping.

If people are still clicking your ads but fewer are registering, attending, or purchasing, investigate where the drop-off is happening.

4. Your audience’s buying behavior genuinely changes during the holidays.

Some businesses do experience slower sales cycles or reduced demand in December. If your historical data supports that, adjusting your strategy may make sense.

5. You don’t have a plan for following up with leads.

If you’re generating leads but nobody is available to follow up with them, you could be wasting opportunities. This is especially important for businesses that rely on sales calls.

The point isn’t that you should always keep your ads running.

It’s that you should have an actual reason for turning them off.

And “it’s Thanksgiving” isn’t automatically a good one.

What I’d Recommend Doing Before Changing Your Holiday Ad Strategy

Before you make any big changes to your Facebook advertising campaigns this holiday season, take a few minutes to look at the bigger picture.

First, review your historical performance.

If you’ve advertised during previous holiday seasons, what actually happened? Did your costs increase? Did sales decline? Or did your campaigns continue generating a healthy return?

Second, look beyond the cost per lead.

If you’re running a webinar, challenge, free training, or other lead generation funnel, make sure you’re tracking what happens after someone signs up.

A low CPL is nice. A profitable funnel is better.

Third, avoid making reactive changes based on a few days of data.

Advertising performance naturally fluctuates. One expensive day doesn’t necessarily mean your campaign is falling apart.

Look for meaningful trends before making decisions, while keeping an eye on your budget and profitability.

And finally, remember that your business isn’t everyone else’s business.

What works for a large e-commerce brand running Black Friday promotions may be completely different from what works for a consultant selling a $3,000 program.

Your advertising decisions should reflect your business model, your audience, and your actual results.

Not some blanket rule you heard about holiday advertising.

The Bottom Line: Don’t Let the Calendar Make Your Advertising Decisions

I understand why business owners get nervous about advertising during the holidays.

Nobody wants to waste money, especially when ad costs are increasing.

But automatically turning off your campaigns because it’s Thanksgiving, Christmas, or Black Friday could mean missing out on perfectly good leads and sales.

I’ve seen firsthand what happens when a business stops interrupting successful holiday campaigns and starts making decisions based on the entire funnel instead.

Better consistency. More opportunities to generate sales. And in my client’s case, better ROAS.

The goal isn’t to get the cheapest leads possible. It’s to acquire customers profitably.

And sometimes that means being willing to pay a little more for leads that are worth it.

Not Sure Whether to Keep Your Facebook Ads Running This Holiday Season?

If you’re looking at rising ad costs and wondering whether you should keep going, scale back, or make some changes, you don’t have to guess.

In a Meta Ads Strategy Intensive, we’ll go through your ad account together, look at what’s actually happening with your campaigns, and figure out what your numbers are telling us.

We’ll review your settings, identify potential problems, and make sure your strategy makes sense for your business, especially with all the changes Meta keeps rolling out.

The goal is to help you make confident decisions about your advertising instead of reacting to every fluctuation in Ads Manager.

Book Your Meta Ads Strategy Intensive →

Because the last thing you want to do is turn off a campaign that’s making you money just because the calendar says it’s time for turkey.

Leave a Comment