Borrowed Strategies
A client called me a little while back, fired up from her mastermind call.
“A lot of the women in my group are leaving Meta ads,” she told me. “They say there are too many spam bot leads. Should we be doing the same?”
My first reaction was to ask a simple question: “What are they doing instead to get new leads?”
She didn’t know.
And that’s usually where these conversations start to unravel.
The half-story problem
When someone shares what’s working – or not working – for them in a mastermind, you’re usually only hearing half the story.
You’re hearing the strategy. You’re not hearing the audience size, the budget, the team, the backup plan, or the years of work that make that strategy viable for them specifically.
The women leaving Meta ads? Some of them have massive email lists of active, engaged buyers they can live off of for months. Others have established YouTube channels driving consistent traffic. A few have been building their businesses for a decade and have enough momentum to experiment with pulling back on paid ads entirely.
And some of them might be making a mistake they don’t know yet. You’re hearing the announcement, not the outcome. A month from now, they might quietly turn their ads back on and never mention it in the group. But the follow-up – whether it actually worked – that part doesn’t always make it back to the group.
That context changes everything.
Without it, “we’re leaving Meta ads” sounds like a bold, confident move worth copying.
With it, it’s a very specific decision that only makes sense for a very specific situation.
And the bot problem they mentioned? There’s a simple fix most people don’t know about. You can eliminate the majority of bots by excluding network audience as a placement. Two clicks. Problem solved.
But that detail never made it into the mastermind conversation.
What you’re actually seeing
Masterminds can be incredible. The shared knowledge, the community, the access to people who are a few steps ahead – all genuinely valuable.
But they can also create a dangerous illusion: that because something is working for someone at your level, it should work for you too.
The person sharing their strategy isn’t trying to mislead you. They’re sharing what’s true for them. But what’s true for them is inseparable from their specific situation – their audience, their budget, their team, their stage of business.
When you hear “I’m doing XYZ and it’s working,” what you’re really hearing is “I’m doing XYZ and it’s working given everything else that’s true about my business that I’m not mentioning right now.”
The question nobody asks
Before you borrow someone else’s strategy, ask one question: “What else is true about their business that makes this work?”
Big email list? Established social following? Large team? Years of brand recognition? Completely different niche?
Because the strategy is never the whole story. The situation is.
My client who wanted to leave Meta ads has a small but growing audience, a modest budget, and no other reliable lead generation channel. Leaving Meta ads wouldn’t be a bold move. It would be turning off her only lead source.
So we’re not leaving Meta ads. We’re fixing the bot problem in two clicks and getting back to work.
The bottom line
The most dangerous business advice isn’t bad advice. It’s good advice borrowed from the wrong situation.
Before you copy someone else’s strategy, make sure you’re also copying their circumstances. And if you’re not – if your audience, budget, team, and stage of business look nothing like theirs – the strategy probably won’t land the same way.
What works for Suzy works for Suzy. Figure out what works for you.
So here’s my question for you this week: Where are you borrowing someone else’s strategy without fully understanding the situation behind it?
And what would change if you asked “what else is true about their business” before making your next move?
Comment and tell me what you think. I read every comment, and I love hearing from you.